Whistling Ridge

A friend recently extended an invitation to help fight the installation of  wind turbines in the Columbia Gorge at the Whistling Ridge Energy Project, near White Salmon, Washington.

Anyone who knows this region, knows that wind turbines have radically altered the landscape. Instead of miles of open space and rolling hills, there are now miles of huge, noisy turbines, doing their relatively small bit to feed our hunger for energy.

We love green energy (if there is such a thing) and it’s ironic that conservationists are fighting what is perhaps the greenest of green energy. This project application is for 50 turbines, capable of supplying enough energy for 20,000 homes, in an area of the state hit hard by the recession.  It is on private timberland. It is also home to endangered spotted owls, bats and other birds known to be vulnerable to wind turbines, and it borders the Columbia National Gorge Scenic area.  Both the Forest Service and the National Park Service have raised objections.

It sounds like this particular project might be poorly sited, but I can’t bring myself to fight it.

Wind turbines, which ten years ago seemed exciting and hopeful, are now visible blight.  It feels like penance for north westerners, who are in other ways isolated from the dark side of energy production.  There are few coal mines here.  We do not allow oil drilling off our shores.  The local nuclear power projects were long ago shut down in disgrace.  Much of our power comes from hydroelectric dams, which play havoc on the salmon population and on riparian areas, but the damage is subtle.  It’s nothing like blowing off mountain tops or drilling 5 miles under the sea floor.  The weather is mild, and we can hardly function if it snows an inch or two, let alone a midwestern foot.  It is easy for us to rest in our comforts, our access to fresh food, spacious countryside, and we guzzle energy like there is no tomorrow, just like everybody else.  Yes, the wind turbines are an affront to the wild and open space that is our cultural and physical heritage.  They are dangerous to wildlife.  Yes we should fight to site them appropriately, but the bigger fight, the important fight, is to face the growing dependency, to recognize how connected we all are in this problem, and to change.

If we want to keep our comforts, no, increase our comforts (as the economics of growth demands), we will have to put up with nuclear power plants, and coal power plants, and more dams, more solar power plants and yes, more wind turbines.  It will cause more coal mining deaths, more nuclear power accidents, more disrupted riparian ecosystems, and probably climate change.  I don’t believe that a miraculous discovery is going to save us.  We are going to have to drive less, share more, pick away at  new kinds of energy generation, and we still might not be able to prevent chaos for the next generation.  It is discouraging.  Whistling Ridge is the tip of the iceberg.

http://org2.democracyinaction.org/o/5111/p/dia/action/public/?action_KEY=5051, http://whistlingridgeenergy.com/site/?cat=4


  • The blight factor is a big deal and not often justified, economically. Just another case of Man trying to fix something by building stuff. Beware of wind industry claims of “X-thousand” homes a wind site will supposedly power. It’s usually based on best case scenarios and many wind turbines produce only 20% to 30% of their rated output.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Wind turbines on a giant scale bring gigantic new problems. I’d forgotten I’d written this. Interesting to see how little has changed in four years. There is more acceptance of changing climate, but not much progress in the recognition of how we think of energy generation. Thanks for your comment, and for your in depth article on the problems with, and a few good things about, wind energy. http://enough_already.tripod.com/wind_turblight.html


Submit a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s