Follow-up Friday: Is this who we are?

What do you think about the torture report?


A follow-up on Guantanamo detainee Abu Wa’el Dhiab, a Syrian whose story appeared here in Scribbler’s Playhouse. Dhiab filed suit against the US military, claiming that the methods used in Guantanamo for force-feedings were a form of torture. He was one of six detainees released to Uruguay earlier this month. 

Abu Wa’el Dhiab, ISN (Prisoner No.) 722. Photo Source: Eurasia Review

Dhiab, married and a father of four, was in Afghanistan at the start of the post-9/11 war.  He moved his family — illegally — to Pakistan.


He was arrested in a night raid on his house by Pakistani police in 2002. His captors were probably paid a bounty to turn him over to the U.S. He was not charged with any crime. According to Dhiab, he sold honey, traveled to Afghanistan and Pakistan to avoid war, protect his family and for medical treatment.

US military court documents from 2008 (later published by the the New York Times) state that Dhiab, his wife and four children, received financial help from Al Qai’da. Some witnesses claimed he specialized in forgery. He’d been condemned to death in absentia by the Assad government. He might — or might not — have been part of a Sunni terrorist cell. Dhiab was deemed a threat by US military authorities, who recommended that he be detained indefinitely.

In 2009, that recommendation was reversed. He was cleared for release.

It was a struggle to find a country that would take him. Since he was condemned to death in Syria, he couldn’t return there.

The Uruguayan President, Jose Mujica, a former political prisoner himself, agreed to take six of the detainees who had been cleared, including Abu Wa’el Dhiab.

Jose Mujica, President of Uruguay. Known for his frugal habits, Mujica spent 13 years as a political prisoner, two of those years in solitary confinement. About the Guantanamo detainees, he said. “It’s a very traumatic situation, I can’t transmit how they must feel, some of us have lived through similar things.” Quote from The Guardian. Photo by Vince Alongi

Their release was delayed by US paperwork; and also to avoid it becoming an issue in Uruguayan elections. There are only about 300 Muslims in Uruguay and not everyone was comfortable offering sanctuary to the detainees.

Once the election was over, arrangements were made, and the transfer went smoothly.

Of the six released prisoners, Dhiab arrived in the worst shape. He’s 6’5″, 148 pounds, confined to a wheel chair. He will be hospitalized for awhile. One of his four children died during his incarceration. He is working to have the rest of his family join him.

* * *

When they were released from Guantanamo, Abu Wa’el Dhiab, three other Syrians, a Tunisian and a Palestinian, flew on a U.S. military jet in shackles, “ear protectors” and handcuffs.

When the detainees landed, the Uruguayans insisted that the shackles be removed and that they walk off the plane as free men. They were warmly greeted. They are being housed by the local union, and have been offered jobs.

One, Abedlhadi Omar Faraj, wrote a letter thanking the Uruguayans:

“Were it not for Uruguay, I would still be in the black hole in Cuba today. … It is difficult for me to express how grateful I am for the immense trust that you, the Uruguayan people, placed in me and the other prisoners when you opened the doors of your country to us.”

*  *  *

On torture: we’ll never know if the US courts would have ruled that Dhiab’s treatment was a form of torture, but the recent congressional report on torture in other US prisons is pretty damning.

Scribbler sides with Ronald Reagan, who signed the Convention against Torture. That document declares that torture can be used under “no exceptional circumstances, whatsoever.”

Reagan’s aide and George W. Bush’s point man in Iraq Paul Bremer also said: “A major element of our strategy has been to delegitimize terrorists, to get society to see them for what they are – criminals – and to use democracy’s most potent tool, the rule of law, against them.”

John McCain might have put it best this month when he said torture “produces more misleading information than actionable intelligence” and that “we can and we will” win the war on terrorism without torture.  … [T]his question isn’t about our enemies; it’s about us. It’s about who we were, who we are and who we aspire to be. It’s about how we represent ourselves to the world.”

A holiday wish: that more leaders follow McCain’s lead and speak out against torture in any form, and that President Obama fulfills his promise to close Guantanamo.

What are your holiday wishes for the world? 



    • Looking forward to that day. Always thought that truth would be cleared once I reached adulthood, but alas, more often than not things still seem pretty muddy. Here’s to dogma turning to dust.

      Liked by 1 person

  • I figure who best to give us an accurate account of torture and the information it produces than someone who’s been through it him or herself? That’s why I think we’d be wise to listen to John McCain on this issue. America should not stand for torture–literally or figuratively.


  • Our use of torture brought shame on America. In the eyes of the rest of the world we are rightfully seen as torturers. My father and many of his pals served in WWII and the Korean War. I grew up thinking that we were superior because we did not torture and commit war crimes like the Germans, Japanese, and North Koreans did. That superiority is long gone now.

    Liked by 1 person

  • YES- loudly YES, Scribbler. Regan and McCain and all the others who can see evil for what it is. We are destroying our soul- not to mention the terrible crimes we, as a country with our tax dollars, have perpetrated.


  • I fervently hope this is NOT who we are, but sadly, there is much evidence to the contrary. My wish for the world is limitless compassion–enough of it to flow over and heal every broken being, angry fighter, and damaged soul,


  • What I wish and what will be are so far apart, I’ve come to recognize the US isn’t going to make any significant changes for the better in my lifetime. I saw too much as a fed to believe any different. On the subject of torture, I’ve always believed it was wrong. However, I honestly believe greater harm was done when the report was made public. That did not have to happen. The report could have been gained under the Freedom of Information Act without a problem.
    The same individuals demanding the release of the Torture Report never take the time to read and comment on Administrative Laws that change the very fabric of their lives. In essence, they (we) are allowing themselves (ourselves) to be tortured by their (our) own government.


    • We in the US may surprise ourselves. Time and again, just when it seems our darkest hour, we undergo revolutionary and transformational change. You’re absolutely right. More of us need to read and understand the laws beneath the laws that affect all of us. It’s one of the things I try to do when researching for this blog. Thanks for the comment. Warmest wishes for the holidays.


  • It’s as simple as 2 wrongs don’t make a right, yet it is so difficult to see. The hateful media frenzy on this subject just adds more fuel to the hateful fire that has been burning for way too long.
    I always wish for Peace.


  • I agree, especially about the media. It’s equally disturbing that, once the frenzy passes, the stories disappear in order make way for another frenzy.

    Peace to you and yours this holiday.


Submit a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s