Yes, you (probably) get more than enough protein

Americans are crazy about protein.

images.duckduckgo.jpg

download-2.jpgimages.jpgdownload.jpg

You can even buy high protein water.

download-1.jpg

Do we need all that protein? No.

Do we need meat to get the protein we need? No (unless you have a medical condition).

Do we have to combine “complementary” plant sources to get the protein we need? Nope.

How much do we get? 

Worldwide, the average healthy person’s diet is about 4 to 5% protein. To be extra safe, the USDA set the minimum recommended daily requirement at double that amount, 8 – 10% of total calories, enough to generously meet the needs of our largest citizens. Most of us get a lot more than that. The average woman needs about 50 – 70 grams per day, and the average man about 60 – 80. Americans get around 120 grams per day.

There’s nothing wrong with a little extra. But 4 or 5 times more than recommended? Diets with too much protein are associated with increased risks of osteoporosis, kidney disease, cancer and heart disease.

Also, since we get most of our protein from animals, too much is hard on the environment.

Screen Shot 2017-09-15 at 5.13.44 PM.png
SOURCE: World Resources Institute

 

How much do we need?

That depends on how old you are, whether you are an athlete, your health, your muscle mass and how active you are. Below are resources if you’re in the mood to dig, or check with your physician, but the basic rule of thumb for an average person:

.8 grams of protein per kilogram body weight, or .36 grams per pound

For a 160 pound person: .36 grams  x  160 pounds = 57.6 grams

How much protein can we get from plants? 

All of it.

Screen Shot 2017-09-15 at 4.47.56 PM.png
SOURCE: World Resources Institute

It’s true that not all plants have equal amounts of amino acids, the building blocks of proteins. Some are low in the amino acids the body doesn’t produce on its own, aka “essential” amino acids. In 1971, Frances Moore Lappé’s pioneering cookbook instructed vegetarians to combine, say, rice with beans, complementary proteins, to make sure of an adequate supply of essential amino acids.

images.duckduckgo-1.jpg

We’ve since learned this is a myth (France Lappė corrects the mistake in later editions). The truth is:

  1. All edible plants contain all amino acids.
  2. While some plants are low in essential amino acids, a varied diet fills in most of the gaps. Eating whole plants can provide not just the minimum requirements, but more than the recommended requirements.
  3. Most of us have access to many plants offering a complete set of essential amino acids, including buckwheat, quinoa, soy and potatoes.

I’m not a vegetarian, but I’ve cut back on protein from animals, and stopped worrying about whether I’m getting enough.

If you’re a normal, healthy, red-blooded American, you probably should, too.

**Two demographic sets who tend to be low in protein intake in the U.S.: teen girls and the elderly.

Sources:

Christopher Gardner, Stanford

Protein Overload, Civil Eats

Food Myths, Fortune Magazine 

DGAC Sustainability guidelines not adopted, Yale Environmental Review

Stop Freaking Out, Mother Jones

Drawbacks to High Protein diets, Physicians Committee for Responsible Health

RDA vs. Dietary Guidelines, Micaela Karlsen

Complete Protein Calculator

8 comments

  • This a great article. Very comprehensive. It’s true, many people get more protein than they need, especially if they’re meat eaters. But as you mention, there are many non-meat sources of protein as well, and they’re often so good for us. For example, beans and legumes. Many Greek yogurt brands also have a lot of protein in them. We just have to make sure it doesn’t have a lot of added sugar too!

    Liked by 2 people

  • I remember a handmade chart labeled “Complementary Proteins” taped to the wall of a rental house kitchen long ago, with columns for all the foods and how to pair them, strictly according to Frances Moore Lappé. Do you remember that? 🙂 Thanks for this detailed and interesting update!

    Like

    • I remember! My dog-eared copy of Frances Moore Lappė’s book holds an honored place among my cookbooks. She was, and still is, a pioneer, and I’m still a fan.

      Like

  • Glad you brought attention to this topic. The media tends to demonize carbs ( justified when it comes to refined carbs, not so with whole grains, legumes other whole and unprocessed carbs), fats ( again not always justified unless we are talking trans fats and excessive amounts of saturated fats), while putting protein on a pedestal. There is a slew of emerging research that demonstrates that a westernized diet high in animal protein and undesirable fats may be linked with disrupting the balance of good and bad bacteria in the gut which in turn can set the inflammatory tone in the body, plant based proteins create a more optimal ratio of “friendly ” to harmful bacteria. And that’s not even scratching the surface! This is a very important topic that needs to be brought to the attention of the public, and to this end, I have discussed it on my blog under “gut bacteria”. Thank you for putting this crucial topic in the spotlight:))

    Liked by 1 person

Submit a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s